Our Fast Intent
C.S. Lewis’s The Abolition of Man, the Dao, and Being Water in the Age of AI.
“Behold they are one people, and they all have the same language. And this is what they began to do.”
— Genesis 11:6, NASB

It is difficult to appreciate language as a technology because we use it so naturally. By the time we have developed the capacity to think about language in the abstract we have already forgotten to think about it at all. Perhaps that is why Large Language Models like Claude and ChatGPT are so seductive. We read and hear them speaking in a human way, and ascribe human qualities to them without thinking. Animals like dolphins and even bees can communicate with each other, but communication is not language. Language is uniquely human. We do it spontaneously and imaginatively. It is the foundation upon which all the greatest collaborative achievements of our race have been built (hence the tower of Babel), and yet languages are dying. Globalization and political forces have already reduced the number of languages, but I would argue that, especially as an English speaker, our own relationship to our mother tongue is coming under attack. Readers are reading less and easier books. Writing jobs are being poached by LLMs. And even if we don’t use AI, most of us live in such a perpetually hurried and worried state that we rarely use language for anything more than animal communication. Is it any wonder then, that the technology that has even its creators prophesying about doomsday, is built around human language?[^1]
I don’t care to go on dooming about AI. I think we are all pretty anxious about it. Rather, I would like to look into sources from the past to think about how we can respond. It gets a little dark and confusing, because that’s where C.S. Lewis goes in The Abolition of Man, but there is light at the end of tunnel. The light of The Way, or 道 “Dao,” a concept and word which Lewis borrows from the ancient Chinese text, 道德经 “The Dao de Jing.”[^2]
What I discovered in writing this essay is that “frontier” technology like AI is forcing us all to finally ask ourselves what it means to be human. We can no longer live in denial about the direction this road is taking us. One way leads to a rejection of our past and our humanity, the other leads to life. Far from curing cancer, AI simply reveals the cancer that has been growing in our civilization since at least the 1950s, but I suspect it has been a human problem from the beginning (as we will see with Shakespeare’s King Lear). But we do not have to despair (forever).